Many parents know the rhythm of an engaged school community — committees made up of staff and parents working together to support the environment where our children grow and learn. But at Eureka Day School, the board’s involvement extends far beyond bake sales and spring concerts. These members take their roles seriously, striving to build a space that is not only nurturing, but deeply healthy and inclusive for everyone.
That dynamic is at the heart of Eureka Day by Jonathan Spector — a wildly funny and razor-sharp satire now on stage in Toronto at the Coal Mine Theatre.
Eureka Day Synopsis: The play is set at The Eureka Day School, a private elementary school in Berkeley, California. The five board members uphold strong progressive ideals: representation, acceptance, and social justice. In weekly meetings, Eureka Day’s board members develop and update policy to preserve this culture of inclusivity, reaching decisions but only by consensus.
But when a mumps outbreak threatens the community, facts become subjective and every solution divisive. The school’s leadership is left to confront the central question: How do you build consensus when no one can agree on truth? This play exposes the underlying instincts of a community that defines itself by their polished consideration of differing opinions but is in fact a hotbed of intolerance.
Acclaimed COAL MINE collaborator Mitchell Cushman returns to the Danforth for the production, directing an all-star cast –all making their COAL MINE debuts– including Kevin Bundy (Cock),Jake Epstein (Life, After), Sarah McVie (Workin’ Moms), Stephanie Sy (Next to Normal, Fubar) and Sophia Walker (Slave Play) and Abigail Whitney (Amazon’s The Boys)
Recently, Sarah McVie made time to chat with us about her character Suzanne in Eureka Day…
We know you from Working Moms the television series. Now, you’re stepping into another mom character role in the current stage production of Eureka Day! Tell us what’s that like for you going from TV to acting on stage?
Sarah: Theatre is my first love and this return to my roots has been splendid in so many ways! The process is always guided by the director and Mitchell has mapped out a journey that included something called “table work”, a real rarity in TVand film work. Led by his thoughtful and insightful direction we spent time at the start considering the details imbedded in this fabulous text written by Jonathan Spector. I relish time spent exploring creative possibilities with my fellow actors in a rehearsal room and that was one element of the experience of acting that I have missed.
The challenge for me has been adjusting to the rigour and repetition involved in stage play. With a tv gig you show up with everything completely memorized and there isn’t much time to rehearse so you are thrown bits of direction as you film and it’s all about delivering on the day and then it’s done.
The need to reproduce a moment over and over and over (we just got extended so I’ll add) over and over and over again requires a kind of discipline and technique that I practiced in my early career performing Shakespeare in repertory (doing several plays in rotation) as a member of the Stratford Festival of Canada for five seasons. It’s a challenge I’m enjoying, and I anticipate enjoying every single fresh performance of this truly exciting piece of theatre!
Can you tell us about your character Suzanne in Eureka Day? What kind of parent is she?
Sarah: Suzanne is a devoted parent of 3 children who believes that her primary responsibility is to create opportunity for them to learn and grow with positivity, safety and joy. She is also very conscious of the importance of community and instills in her children a sense of social responsibility, encouraging them to embrace ideals like generosity and respect.
Suzanne, like all of us, has her own partialities that influence her choices and potentially lead her to act against her own values. She works tirelessly for the Eureka Day school she has built for over a decade alongside other dedicated parents and caregivers, sacrificing her own comfort to ensure its success. She is a force to be reckoned with and so much more than the stereotypical “PTA Mom” we have learned to recognize and associate with descriptions like “extra” and “annoying”. Suzanne is intelligent, driven and trying to do “the right thing” as a socially conscious and caring citizen.
How do you balance Suzanne’s seriousness with the Eureka Day’s sharp humour?
Sarah: That seriousness is something I relate to myself. I’ve been working on this social justice issue within my own residential community for a few years now and in my role as an advocate I tap into the fortitude and determination I absorbed watching my own parents in their accomplished careers in the public service and now carry on in their unrelenting volunteerism in retirement. I was raised to value compassion, equality and dignity of all persons and when I can have a positive influence on other people I do my best to rise to the occasion.
My silly side and my approach to comedy is grounded in the idea that life is full of challenge and suffering is inevitable and to my mind an artist is tasked with evoking a response that involves recognition and provokes thought. Whether the intended response is anything from tears to laughter the foundation of the work is always seeking to illuminate the truth of our complex shared humanity.
What was the biggest challenge in playing Suzanne?
Sarah: The play is written with an internal rhythm that mimics how people naturally interact when they are discussing important ideas and are all very passionate about sharing their perspective. Every character is fighting to make their point while also making space for others to do the same and this leads to overlapping lines and cut offs (when you start speaking before the other person has finished their thoug–).
Finding the connection between thoughts and the shifts in direction, which often unfolds at a lighting pace and requires intense listening, quick thinking and precise delivery is a challenge that I haven’t experienced for many years. This play is like metcon fitness workout for acting chops and feeling those muscles flex again has been a joyous reawakening!
If Suzanne could speak directly to the audience after the play ends, what do you think she would want them to understand about her?
Sarah: “I always wanted the best for everyone but my children are my first priority, do you blame me?”

We understand you’re a “bonus mom” IRL (we love that!). Has Eureka Day changed the way you perceive other parents involvement at all?
Sarah: I love being a BONUS MOM! They have been in my life for just over 3 years now and I absolutely adore them. I can’t speak to being a primary parent, a biological parent or a legal guardian—I’m only completely responsible for two amazing dogs named Coco and Morgan.
Even as a part time bonus mom I am finally getting a taste of the relentless work it takes to be a great caregiver for young people these days. The pressure to have them participating in lots of activities, the need to take time to read with them, find opportunities for learning and fun and exercise and also get lunches made and dinners planned and prepared and teeth brushed (properly!) and so on and so on! It’s absolutely consuming and exhausting when done with their best interests at heart.
“I wish more parents had a bigger village of aunties and bonus parents and caregivers to give them support and relief because it really is too much to do alone.”
It’s that whole it takes a village idea that I completely believe in and so it’s fitting that I am one of those villagers helping whoever is in my sphere. The frustrating part for anyone in my position is that at the end of the day it’s not my decision to make and so there has to be a lot of letting go of control and that is a good practice for me as someone who tends to take the lead in many situations.
I wanted my own biological child. I tried. Hard. My fertility journey ended in 2021 just before we filmed season 6 of Workin’ Moms. I’d already spent years as a proud aunt to my sister’s 3 amazing daughters and saw firsthand the need for youth centered advocacy in our social systems like education and health care. I was planning to take on that advocacy as I raised my own kid and had even managed to purchase a home in my chosen city of Toronto thinking it would be the home where I would raise my own family.
Not long after coming to terms with the door closing on having my own biological child I fell madly in love with a neighbour up the street. I hired his and his brother-in-law to build a gazebo. This while I was going to work and acting out a handman turned life partner/blended family with TWO BOYS storyline! Val and Mel became Sarah and Rui, playing Val who has two boys and who marries her handsome handyman Mel at the end of the series that summer! Rui and the boys moved in last year and we have a happy home.
I must thank those Workin’ Moms writers for producing the magically manifested storyline that has changed my life for the better. Being a bonus mom is awesome and in the end the freedom I enjoy because they have a second happy home for alternating weeks gives me the opportunity to pursue the acting and advocacy work I love.
What do you wish people would ask you about returning to the stage…er, or parenting ?
Sarah: “What took you so long to get back on stage Sarah?” You tell me! Being an actor means being at the mercy of others wanting you to join the party! You need other people to make the thing happen. Which is a theme in the play too. I love collaboration and being on a team so the only thing that’s kept me away is the right invitation. With this Coalmine gig it was an immediate yes please and it’s a privilege to be in the company of some of the best theatre creators in Toronto. I hope this leads to more theatre gigs! Just to be clear I’m also open to another killer comedy tv series like Workin’ Moms!
The feedback I get from fans all over the world continues to fuel me through those inevitable periods of rejection that are a part of the actor’s life. As for questions I’d like to get about parenting — I have so many strong opinions and I’m working on only sharing them when they are invited or the intended ear is willing to listen. Because like I said—it’s tough being a parent and I get that.
“It’s tough being a parent and I get that.”
I wish people would ask me what they think is a priority for parenting kids these days. Then I would launch into my pitch that it is to GET THEM OFF THE SCREENS! Make them read, play with LEGO, do crafts, be in nature, be bored, play sports or do drama. Do anything where they are alert and awake in the lived reality of this amazing world!
The science is there and the tech executives don’t let their own kids have ipads and phones etc. I try not to judge because of course I am far from perfect myself but I have a hard time keeping that particular opinion to myself right now as I’ve seen firsthand the harm it can do to young people. My friends get annoyed when I talk about this so I’ve been trying not to go on about it but you asked what I wanted asked and so there it is! Maybe I’m more of a Suzanne than I would like to admit…you’ll have to come see the play and then judge for yourself!
Eureka Day by Jonathan Spector, and directed by Mitchell Cushman, is now playing at Toronto’s Coal Mine Theatre until March 1, 2026.
“Critic’s Pick! Jonathan Spector’s lively portrait of a debate over mandatory vaccinations is the perfect play for our age of disagreement. …characters who had seemed so easy to ridicule as stereotypes acquire a substance and specificity that inhibit both derision and facile categorization. It becomes possible to identify with each of these people…no matter what your own feelings about vaccination are. This means that EUREKA DAY…is not only one of the funniest plays to open this year, it is one of the saddest.”
—The New York Times
*Photos by Elana Emer Photography
*****


